The world may be my oyster, but I’m allergic to shellfish
Melancholic songwriting about love gone wrong is a dime a dozen. Quality is in short supply when everyone and their kid sister is uploading a sappy ballad onto YouTube. That’s why Spring Breakup is worth a million damn dollars.
Earlier this year the duo quietly (practically silently) put out their sophomore album. You’ll recall their debut got me pretty excited. Mathais Kom is one of the most brilliant songwriters in Canada, his wit and dour world view complement each other perfectly. Kim Barlow is a delightful foil, all precious and precocious and every bit as subtly withdrawn when the moment calls for it.
It’s Not Me, It’s You fleshes out their previous recordings by adding a percussion to a number of songs. It’s a small change that yields big results right from the first track. Bongos (or hand drums, whatever you want to call them) add some playful character to the title track, shakers liven up “The Effect I Have On Women” and a full drum kit propels the group’s fastest-paced number, the absolutely perfect “Never Eat Alone.” And that’s just the first three songs.
Aside from adding the occasional rhythm section elements the music hews pretty closely to their previous work. Bright ukelele and banjo parts serve as counterpart to the down-in-the-dumps tenor of the lyrics, while acoustic guitar and even a very rare bit of electric guitar (on the super-dour “Puppy Dogs & Rainbows”) make an appearance. The songs are short and simply-crafted, catchy vessels for some very purposeful words.
As is usually the case with Kom’s work the lyrics are the focal point. The genesis of Spring Breakup is to tell stories of relationships ending. And they don’t end well. The group even brought a tape recorder on tour after putting out their debut so they could record the worst break-up stories their audience members had to tell. The intent was to write a song for each of them, although there was apparently too much material to work with.
Love songs work because they’re universal; it’s something virtually everyone everywhere can identify with. I suppose lost-love songs work for the same reason. And trust me, lost-loves songs of varying degrees of seriousness are the real winners on It’s Not You, It’s Me. “Never Eat Alone” is, as mentioned, brilliant. The upbeat track tells a heartbreaking tale of a woman on the wrong side of a break-up, one who has to deal with not being ready to say goodbye. The simple picture of someone who can’t bear to eat dinner alone and thus shares their meal time with their dog is heart-rending enough, but Barlow’s fragile alto lends the track an authentic fragility that does just as much as the words for the sentiment.
“Never Eat Alone” comes at the perfect moment in the album too. Opening with the lighter, more humorous “The Effect I Have On Women” and “It’s Not Me, It’s You” disarms the listener. The trade-offs between Barlow and Kom on those tracks paints the picture of a pair of swaggering lotharios (can ladies be considered lotharios?) who can get anyone they desire and drop them just as easily without the slightest bit of remorse. The romantic invincibility outlined on those songs makes the wounded tenor of “Never Eat Alone” hit like a ton of bricks.
Kom also brings his dark humour to the track “Mother and Wife,” on which he asks listeners to consider who they’d save from a burning building first: their dearly beloved or their dear sweet mother. If you’ve been paying attention it isn’t hard to guess which side Kom comes down on. Never resorting to cheap-shots, the songs here are more about romantics who act more like cads, but not purposefully. They just don’t know any better.
There’s definitely no sophomore slump here. Spring Breakup came out of the gate with a clear mandate and intent for their music and they’re sticking to the same basic blueprint here. But their well-written, precocious, sometimes precious, songs are also moving beyond their debut’s tentative first steps. It’s a formula that works so well it’s downright ridiculous. It’s just a shame they’ve chosen to do everything so low-key. If they were able to get some promotion behind this thing they could really have something moderately big on their hands instead of providing a ridiculous amount of joy to the small amount of people that have been lucky enough to stumble upon them.
Spring Breakup - Never Eat Alone [1:59m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download
Spring Breakup - It's Not Me, It's You [3:39m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download





