Advice no one should need
When I was in University I edited and wrote for my school’s student newspaper, the Carillon. I also had an advice column for the romantically retarded. It was called the Book of Love (for what should be obvious reasons). That title had nothing to do with Stephin Merritt.
But there is a tangential connection. At the time I had no business dispensing advice to people with romantic problems, having fallen into a series of ineffective and one-sided relationships with sexually aggressive women with low self-esteem (how little things change). The advice that came out of that piece of work was based more around a loose concept of what should work in any given situation: communication. I’d make a few jokes, impugn someones manhood (either theirs, mine, or their boyfriend), and then tell them to talk about whatever was bothering them with their partner. To say it was half-assed is putting it mildly.
Stephin Merritt, on the other hand, doesn’t do things half-assed and when he bases a project around an idea it comes out a little more successful. That’s what lead to the release of 69 Love Songs a little more than ten years ago. The triple album was less a collection of love songs and more a collection of songs about love songs.
Of course, that would be nearly impossible to pull off without penning a few earnest, genuine love songs along the way. “The Book of Love” is a classic of the genre, covered by a variety of artists that showcases how pervasive and wide-raging Merritt’s work really is. Peter Gabriel’s version is best-known, a treacly string-bomb that was included in a romantic comedy starring (blech) Richard Gere. Quirk-filled singer-songwriter and former Soul Coughing frontman Mike Doughty offers a rather faithful live take, although he drops a few notes here and there (Fleet Foxes singer Robin Pecknold’s take is also pretty straight-forward). British multi-instrumentalist Catherine A.D. released a version on her first EP, flipping the acoustic guitar for piano, synths, and some masked glock.
Then there’s Library Voices. Regina’s highest-profile band of 2009 start with electric guitar as the lead instead of acoustic, but they keep the reverb wet and roomy. One singer keeps Merritt’s baritone melody intact while Carl Johnson overlays the same melody an octave higher, giving the lyrics extra weight and depth. Two-thirds of the way through an authoritative drum line, tambourine, and some ethereal synths give the track a strong full-band finish. The band, notorious for its double-digit membership, keeps restraint at the forefront by including nothing that’s unnecessary. The gorgeous arrangement is simultaneously at odds with and complementary to Merritt’s original; moving beyond the sparse arrangement conflicts with Merritt’s slavish devotion to the idea as the sole focal point, but I’ll be damned if this track isn’t pretty enough to be an inspiration for the 70th love song song.
Library Voices - the Book of Love [3:29m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download
Magnetic Fields - the Book of Love [2:42m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download
Peter Gabriel - the Book of Love [3:37m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download
Mike Doughty - the Book of Love [3:17m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download
Catherine AD - the Book of Love [2:56m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download
Robin Pecknold - the Book of Love [2:34m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | DownloadYou can get their album in any fine record store and on zunior and iTunes.







